STEWARDS’ REPORT
SELANGOR TURF CLUB AUGUST MEETING 2023
SATURDAY, 19 AUGUST 2023
STATE OF TRACK: Good
Track Two (II)
Panel of Stewards:
2 Members of the Panel selected by the Committee
Mr Fin Powrie (Chief Stipendiary Steward)
Mr Nigel Chong (Stipendiary Steward)
Mr Jarry Chong (Stipendiary Steward)
Veterinary Surgeons:
Dr James Yu & Dr Melissa Yeap.
RACE 1 (R0883) Class 5B – 1175M (Track II)
2 |
LET’S COME ON BABY (J Low) |
Bumped heavily at the start, becoming unbalanced. *(See Report) |
3 |
ASIAN TIGER (App R Nuqman) |
Crowded on jumping, losing ground. *(See Report) |
5 |
D’GREAT RICH (AK Lim) |
Raced wide when outside the leader. |
6 |
NORTHERN KNIGHT (App A Suriya) |
Veered inwards markedly at the start, severely crowding several runners. *(See Report) |
8 |
M ELEVEN (R Rueven) |
Squeezed on jumping, losing ground. *(See Report). Vet inspection: Lame off fore – 1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo) |
10 |
I AM MIDAS (App S Shazmin) |
Slow into stride. |
On inquiry, App A Suriya (NORTHERN KNIGHT) pleaded guilty to a charge of careless riding under MRA Rule 44(9)(a)(ii) in that he used his whip shortly after the start thereby allowing it to shift in, crowding M ELEVEN onto ASIAN TIGER and LET’S COME ON BABY.
In assessing the penalty, the Stewards took into consideration App A Suriya’s guilty plea, mitigating factors, previous riding record and his submissions on penalty. He was suspended from riding in races for a period of two (2) Malaysian race days, to be deferred, with effect from 28 August 2023 and to expire on 9 September 2023, both dates inclusive. He was advised of his Right of Appeal.
EMERGENCY ACCEPTOR (EA) / SCRATCHING |
|||||
Race |
Horse |
Reason |
Test |
Remark |
|
1 |
D’GREAT EMPRESS |
Swollen near hind |
Vet exam (1 week embargo) |
Course scratching |
|
Note: The above horse(s) will be required to pass the above test(s) before being declared to race again. |
|||||
HORSE(S) WEIGHT DEVIATION OF 15KGS OR MORE |
|||||
Race |
Horse |
Up (+) / Down (-) (in kgs) |
|||
1 |
MY FIRST MILLION |
-21 |
|||
Note: The above horse(s) was/were checked by the Club Veterinary Surgeon and was/were passed fit to start. |
RACE 2 (R0884) Class 5B – 1175M (Track II)
2 |
HORSE KING (AM Aizat) |
Raced keenly in the early stages. |
3 |
AUTUMN BLITZ (AK Lim) |
Rider advised that his whip use bordered on excessive in terms of failing to allow his mount to respond. |
4 |
MISE EN GARDE (App WW Cheah) |
Carried inwards, then held tight when racing fiercely between the 900M and near the 700M, had to be restrained, thereby losing its position. Vet Inspection: Lame off fore – 1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo) |
5 |
RAHOTU (App M Seelan) |
Vet inspection: Heel-bulb injury off hind. |
6 |
RAINBOW FISH (App S Shazmin) |
Restrained when held tight near the 775M. |
7 |
GOOD WARRIOR (HS Gill) |
Crowded and lost its position near the 800M. Vet Inspection: Respiratory distress – 1000M/vet (1 month embargo) |
8 |
SO BEAUTIFUL (S Ruzaini) |
Raced fiercely in the early stages and had to be restrained off heels running to the 800M. |
9 |
DARCI SUPER (KP Lim) |
Slow into stride. Near the 300M, had to be steadied when striding onto heels. |
10 |
LEGACY FIGHTER (V Espindola) |
Raced wide and took the turn into the straight wide. |
EMERGENCY ACCEPTOR (EA) / SCRATCHING |
|||||
Race |
Horse |
Reason |
Test |
Remark |
|
2 |
DETERMINE TO WIN |
Stone-bruised off hind |
Vet exam (1 week embargo) |
Course scratching |
|
Note: The above horse(s) will be required to pass the above test(s) before being declared to race again. |
RACE 3 (R0885) Class 5A – 1175M (Track II)
2 |
JIMMY ZAC (App I Fikri) |
Inclined to lay inwards near the 1000M and was then crowded, thereby tightening runners. Vet inspection: Lame near fore – 1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo) |
3 |
TERMS OF REFERENCE (HS Gill) |
Crossed from its outside stall and caused runner to steady near the 1100M. Rider warned to exercise greater caution. |
6 |
BARBARIAN (Z Khairil) |
Had to be restrained near the 1025M and was then taken wide. |
7 |
MISS MICHELLE (AM Aizat) |
Shifted in, crowding runner near the 1000M and then had to steady to avoid heels. Rider warned to exercise greater caution. |
8 |
QIJI AUSTON (App T Ammar) |
Bumped shortly after the start, losing its forward position. Crowded approaching the winning post. |
10 |
MARTIN VJ (S Hafis) |
Slow into stride. Inclined to lay inwards in the straight and shifted in markedly, struck with the whip with the rider having to stop and straighten on several occasions. Crowded runner near the winning post. |
EMERGENCY ACCEPTOR (EA) / SCRATCHING |
|||||
Race |
Horse |
Reason |
Test |
Remark |
|
3 |
PERFECT BRANDZ |
Bruised off fore suspensory ligament |
Vet exam (1 week embargo) |
Course scratching |
|
3 |
UNLEASH THE DRAGON |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
3 |
MY MONEY |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
Note: The above horse(s) will be required to pass the above test(s) before being declared to race again. |
RACE 4 (R0886) Class 5A – 1175M (Track II)
1 |
DRAGON SANDS (App I Fikri) |
Proved difficult to load. In light of this, the gelding will be required to pass 1 Starting Stall test before being declared to race again. Badly blocked when attempting a run near the 200M and had to be restrained, eventually obtained a clear run in the final 100M. |
2 |
SKYSCRAPER (O Chavez) |
Had to be taken outwards when attempting a run near the 350M. |
3 |
XIONG FONG (AK Lim) |
Bumped heavily at the start. |
5 |
GUILTY PLEASURES (App A Suriya) |
Slow into stride. Dipped near the 1000M. Obliged to race wide in the middle stages. |
7 |
CAORUNN (App R Nuqman) |
Veered outwards at the start, bumping runner. Raced wide in the middle stages. Inclined to lay inwards over the final 200M. Vet inspection: No significant finding. |
8 |
QIJI LOVE (HS Gill) |
Laid in near the 1000M. |
EMERGENCY ACCEPTOR (EA) / SCRATCHING |
|||||
Race |
Horse |
Reason |
Test |
Remark |
|
4 |
MATILDA |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
4 |
PROPLAYER |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
Note: The above horse(s) will be required to pass the above test(s) before being declared to race again. |
RACE 5 (R0887) Class 4B – 1075M (Track II)
1 |
LIMITLESS VENTURE (KP Lim) |
Jumped awkwardly and thereby lost ground. Blocked for a clear run near the 200M. |
2 |
PACIFIC WINDSOR (App R Nuqman) |
Inclined to race greenly in the middle stages. |
3 |
WINNER’S EUPHORIA (App I Fikri) |
After racing wide, was inclined to lay inwards in the straight. |
5 |
NAUGHTY KID (App A Suriya) |
Rider advised to moderate the extent to which he used his whip. |
6 |
IPOH KAIGEH (S Ruzaini) |
Rider questioned as to the reason he did not take a run which presented itself at about the 250M. He advised that the gelding was racing greenly prior to this and he had taken it outwards in an endeavour to obtain a clear passage. Vet inspection: Lame off fore – 1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo) |
7 |
CAPONE (App AB Riduan) |
Sitting on the back of the stalls when the start was effected, thereby slow into stride. |
9 |
INVISIBLE (App WW Cheah) |
Vet inspection: No significant finding. |
10 |
NOVA FACTOR (AM Aizat) |
Rider advised to moderate the extent to which he used his whip. |
EMERGENCY ACCEPTOR (EA) / SCRATCHING |
|||||
Race |
Horse |
Reason |
Test |
Remark |
|
5 |
HAPPY THIRTYNINE |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
5 |
WHIZ FIZZ |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
5 |
ELISE |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
Note: The above horse(s) will be required to pass the above test(s) before being declared to race again. |
|||||
HORSE(S) WEIGHT DEVIATION OF 15KGS OR MORE |
|||||
Race |
Horse |
Up (+) / Down (-) (in kgs) |
|||
5 |
IPOH KAIGEH |
+16 |
|||
Note: The above horse(s) was/were checked by the Club Veterinary Surgeon and was/were passed fit to start. |
RACE 6 (R0888) Class 4B – 1075M (Track II)
Prior to being loaded, it was noticed that the Blinkers on FLAMING PHOENIX (J Low) had come undone, they were subsequently replaced, necessitating a delay.
3 |
SMART RACER (App A Suriya) |
Veered inwards at the start, crowding runner. |
4 |
AIR BOSS (AK Lim) |
Squeezed on jumping. |
5 |
QADIRA MEDINA (S Ruzaini) |
Withdrawn at 2:48pm: Refused to be loaded – 1 Starting Stall test. |
6 |
MOONGATE (L De Souza) |
Jumped inwards, bumping runner, when the start was effected. |
EMERGENCY ACCEPTOR (EA) / SCRATCHING |
|||||
Race |
Horse |
Reason |
Test |
Remark |
|
6 |
QADIRA MEDINA
|
Refused to be loaded |
1 Starting Stall |
Withdrawn at 2:48pm |
|
6 |
VILLAGE PRINCESS |
Bruised off fore suspensory ligament |
Vet exam (1 week embargo) |
Course scratching |
|
Note: The above horse(s) will be required to pass the above test(s) before being declared to race again. |
RACE 7 (R0889) Class 4B – 1075M (Track II)
4 |
PACIFIC PRIME (App R Nuqman) |
Slow into stride and raced wide in the middle stages. |
7 |
FANTASTIC ECLIPSE (F Maynard) |
Withdrawn at 3:12pm: Lame off fore – 1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo) |
EMERGENCY ACCEPTOR (EA) / SCRATCHING |
|||||
Race |
Horse |
Reason |
Test |
Remark |
|
7 |
FANTASTIC ECLIPSE |
Lame off fore |
1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo) |
Withdrawn at 3:12pm |
|
7 |
MIGHT IS RIGHT |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
7 |
TRINITY GRACE |
Fever |
Vet exam (1 week embargo) |
Course scratching |
|
7 |
I’M SMART GREY |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
Note: The above horse(s) will be required to pass the above test(s) before being declared to race again. |
RACE 8 (R0890) Open Novice – 1075M (Track II)
5 |
TAU KEH SOH (R Rueven) |
Raced wide in the middle stages. |
6 |
VALERIE PEGASUS (Z Khairil) |
Fly-jumped at the start and was subsequently slow into stride, then raced greenly. Rider (Dead heat 4th) was reminded of his obligations to ride his mount out fully to the finish. |
8 |
SUPER WHIRLWIND (App I Fikri) |
Rider’s whip became untangled in the horse’s mane near the 350M. |
9 |
QAFILA (E Ferreira) |
Slow into stride. |
RACE 9 (R0891) Metro A – 1275M (Track II)
2 |
KIRIN (App I Fikri) |
Tended to hang out at the turn near the 700M. Vet inspection: Lame off fore. In light of its soundness history, Trainer BT Lim was advised that the gelding will not be permitted to race for a period of 1 month and will be required to undergo a full veterinary examination prior to passing a 1000M/vet test before being declared to race again. |
4 |
TOP KNIGHT (App M Seelan) |
Bumped on jumping. |
5 |
SKYDANCE ECLIPSE (R Rueven) |
Bumped on jumping. |
7 |
XENA (App AB Riduan) |
Carried out at the start then raced wide and took the turn into the straight wide. Rider’s whip and rein became entangled with the rider dropping his near side rein near the 50M. As such, Apprentice will be referred for retraining. |
8 |
CHINESE TEA (S Ruzaini) |
Vet inspection: Lame off fore – 1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo). |
9 |
KONG FU PANDA (J Low) |
From its outside barrier, forced to race wide. |
10 |
FA FA STAR (App T Ammar) |
Veered outwards at the start, carried runner out wide. |
EMERGENCY ACCEPTOR (EA) / SCRATCHING |
|||||
Race |
Horse |
Reason |
Test |
Remark |
|
9 |
ZANJABEEL |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
9 |
HIGH WATER |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
Note: The above horse(s) will be required to pass the above test(s) before being declared to race again. |
RACE 10 (R0892) Class 3 – 1275M (Track II)
1 |
HANDSOME BENZ (HS Gill) |
Slow to begin. Bumped inwards at the 25M. |
3 |
CHICAGO STAR (App WW Cheah) |
Vet inspection: Lame off fore – 1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo). |
4 |
QUICKEN AWAY (S Hafis) |
Sitting back when the start was effected, thereby losing ground. |
5 |
KHAYYAM (O Chavez) |
Withdrawn at 4:41pm: Lame off fore – 1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo). |
6 |
GRAND CHOICE (App A Suriya) |
Saddle slipped backwards on jumping. |
9 |
D’GREAT DUCHESS (App S Shazmin) |
Hung inwards in the straight, bumping runner near the 25M. |
10 |
QIJI ACHEEVA (Z Khairil) |
Whilst being loaded, rider struck his left foot at the stalls. After being examined by the Club Doctor, he was declared unfit to ride for the remainder of the race today. The gelding was subsequently withdrawn at 4:49pm. This necessitated a delay of several minutes. |
EMERGENCY ACCEPTOR (EA) / SCRATCHING |
|||||
Race |
Horse |
Reason |
Test |
Remark |
|
10 |
KHAYYAM
|
Lame off fore |
1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo) |
Withdrawn at 4:41pm |
|
10 |
QIJI ACHEEVA |
Rider injured |
– |
Withdrawn at 4:49pm. |
|
10 |
MALAYSIA CAPTAIN |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
10 |
RESOLUTE |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
10 |
KRUGER |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
Note: The above horse(s) will be required to pass the above test(s) before being declared to race again. |
|||||
HORSE(S) WEIGHT DEVIATION OF 15KGS OR MORE |
|||||
Race |
Horse |
Up (+) / Down (-) (in kgs) |
|||
10 |
EMPEROR TAIZONG |
+17 |
|||
Note: The above horse(s) was/were checked by the Club Veterinary Surgeon and was/were passed fit to start. |
RACE 11 (R0893) Supreme C – 1775M (Track II)
1 |
PASIR PINJI (App T Ammar) |
Laid inwards in the straight causing runner to steady near the 200M. |
2 |
COLONEL CHIEF (S Hafis) |
Sitting back when the start was effected, thereby losing ground. Inclined to lay outwards throughout running. |
4 |
STRAIGHT N ARROW (S Ruzaini) |
Raced wide at the turn out of the straight and then tended to race fiercely in the middle stages. |
9 |
ROYALTY’S WISH (App A Suriya) |
Raced wide in the middle stages. Had to be steadied when crossed near the 200M. Returned having cast near fore plate. |
Jockey O Chavez (FAMOUS NAME) was fined RM250/- for negligence under MRA Rule 152(5)(a) for failing to seek the Stewards’ permission to ride 1/2kg overweight.
EMERGENCY ACCEPTOR (EA) / SCRATCHING |
|||||
Race |
Horse |
Reason |
Test |
Remark |
|
11 |
SHANGHAI CAPTAIN |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
11 |
SACRED GURU |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
Note: The above horse(s) will be required to pass the above test(s) before being declared to race again. |
RACE 12 (R0894) Class 5A – 1775M (Track II)
1 |
ROCK N ROLL (S Hafis) |
Rider was advised that he must moderate; the extent to which he raises the whip and its intended force. |
3 |
GHOST BAY (App R Nuqman) |
Raced wide at the turn out of the straight. |
6 |
TURF PRINCESS (M Ewe) |
Pulled hard in the early stages. |
7 |
D’GREAT SWIFT (S Ruzaini) |
Obliged to race wide throughout. |
8 |
BIG CHINA (HS Gill) |
Pulled hard in the early stages. |
9 |
SUPER ATAS (SU Lim) |
Vet inspection: Lame off fore – 1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo). |
EMERGENCY ACCEPTOR (EA) / SCRATCHING |
|||||
Race |
Horse |
Reason |
Test |
Remark |
|
12 |
KNIGHT COMMAND |
Capacity field |
– |
EA |
|
Note: The above horse(s) will be required to pass the above test(s) before being declared to race again. |
GENERAL REPORT(S) – SLTC
RACE 11 (R847) Class 5 – 1200M (A sc), SUNDAY, 6 AUGUST 2023, SELANGOR TURF CLUB AUGUST MEETING 2023
The Stewards, on Thursday, 10 August 2023, inquired into running and handling of QUASAR in the above race. Evidence was taken from Jockey Z Khairil and Trainer NM Selvan, the rider and trainer of QUASAR respectively.
Trainer NM Selvan stated that he had instructed that QUASAR be ridden in a midfield position as was customary over the 1200M. Whilst he believed the gelding was best suited by racing on a softer track, he was comfortable with the state of the track as being suitable.
Jockey Z Khairil confirmed the instructions and advised that after jumping well, he had been in a nice position midfield, given that the leaders had gone very hard. Running to the 800M turn, he had been outside PACIFIC ARMANI (App R Nuqman) (placed second) and in advance of MARTIN VJ (App A Suriya) (winner) when he attempted to take up a better position closer to the fence but had received an appeal from App A Suriya who he believed was being crowded slightly. He had thus stayed in his three (3) wide position until straightening where he had struck QUASAR back handed on two (2) occasions. He had then ridden in his consistent manner using the whip on numerous occasions. He was of the opinion QUASAR had neither stopped nor progressed finishing a well beaten seventh (7th).
The Stewards advised Jockey Z Khairil that they had concerns related to his true purpose when he had remained in three (3) wide position early in the race. He was advised that he must ride every mount in a purposeful and diligent manner.
Trainer NM Selvan was advised that it was expected that QUASAR be ridden in a similar fashion at its next starts.
RACE 10 (R846) Open Maiden – 1200M (A sc), SUNDAY, 6 AUGUST 2023, SELANGOR TURF CLUB AUGUST MEETING 2023
In review of races from 5th and 6th August 2023, the Stewards reprimanded Jockey KP Lim for continuing to use his whip on MAGIC TURBO in the above race, when the gelding was clearly winning.
RACE 7 (R843) Class 4B – 1100M (A sc), SUNDAY, 6 AUGUST 2023, SELANGOR TURF CLUB AUGUST MEETING 2023
App H Haikal who rode his 10th winner on MR HANKS in this race, would only be entitled to claim 3kgs allowance as from Monday, 7 August 2023.
WITHDRAWAL OF APPEAL BY JOCKEY Y AIFY AGAINST THE SUSPENSION OF SIX (6) MONTHS AND FINE OF RM20,000/- FOR CONTRAVENTION OF MRA RULE 44(10) IMPOSED BY THE PANEL OF STEWARDS RELATED TO HIS RIDING OF RACEHORSE “TORNADO PEGASUS” IN RACE 5 (R662) ON SUNDAY, 18 JUNE 2023 AT THE SELANGOR TURF CLUB JUNE MEETING 2023
Jockey Y Aify (TORNADO PEGASUS) who lodged an appeal against his suspension of six (6) months and fine of RM20,000/- under MRA Rule 44(10), applied to withdraw his appeal on 15 August 2023. Pursuant to MRA Rule 149(1)(h), the Appeal Panel acceded to his request and his deposit shall be forfeited. His suspension commenced on 16 August 2023 and to expire on 15 February 2024, both dates inclusive.
Change of Rider(s)
Race |
Horse |
Rider |
Replaced By |
Reason |
1 |
ASIAN TIGER |
App M Ekdihar |
App R Nuqman |
Medical |
1 |
LUKE MAN |
Unfixed |
L De Souza |
EA |
2 |
ELEGENT |
Unfixed |
SU Lim |
EA |
3 |
CHINO DINERO |
App M Ekdihar |
App S Shazmin |
Medical |
4 |
DRAGON SANDS |
App M Ekdihar |
App I Fikri |
Medical |
5 |
WINNER’S EUPHORIA |
App M Ekdihar |
App I Fikri |
Medical |
8 |
SUPER WHIRLWIND |
App M Ekdihar |
App I Fikri |
Medical |
9 |
KIRIN |
App M Ekdihar |
App I Fikri |
Medical |
11 |
ARTHUR PEGASUS |
Z Khairil |
R Rueven |
Medical |
NON ACCEPTORS |
||||
Race |
Horse |
Reason |
Test |
Remark |
1 |
WINNING SMILE |
Swollen near fore leg |
Vet exam |
|
6 |
MYO |
Stone-bruised off fore foot |
Vet exam |
|
6 |
PERFECT MISSION |
Tied-up |
Vet exam |
– |
9 |
VIOLET |
Bruised near fore & tied-up |
Vet exam |
– |
11 |
LEOPARD ECLIPSE |
Colic |
Vet exam |
– |
11 |
TAUBOSS |
Bumper injury off hind |
Vet exam |
– |
12 |
GOLDEN CRAFTSMAN |
Bruised near fore fetlock |
Vet exam |
– |
Note: The above horse(s) will be required to pass the above test(s) before being declared to race again. |
SLTC, SATURDAY, 19 AUGUST 2023 |
||||||||||||
POST RACE VETERINARY EXAMINATION / REPORT FROM VETERINARY SURGEON – TESTS IMPOSED |
||||||||||||
Race |
Horse |
Reason/Finding |
Test |
Remark |
||||||||
1 |
M ELEVEN
|
Lame off fore |
1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo) |
– |
||||||||
2 |
MISE EN GARDE
|
Lame off fore |
1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo) |
– |
||||||||
2 |
RAHOTU
|
Heel-bulb injury off hind |
– |
– |
||||||||
2 |
GOOD WARRIOR
|
Respiratory distress |
1000M/vet (1 month embargo) |
– |
||||||||
3 |
JIMMY ZAC |
Lame near fore |
1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo) |
– |
||||||||
4 |
DRAGON SANDS
|
Proved difficult to load |
1 Starting Stall |
– |
||||||||
4 |
CAORUNN |
No significant finding |
– |
– |
||||||||
5 |
IPOH KAIGEH |
Lame off fore |
1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo) |
– |
||||||||
5 |
INVISIBLE |
No significant finding |
– |
– |
||||||||
7 |
LEO |
Clipped near fore heel bulb |
– |
– |
||||||||
8 |
QAFILA |
Cut off hind pastern |
– |
– |
||||||||
9 |
KIRIN |
Lame off fore |
1000M/vet (1 month embargo & full vet exam) |
– |
||||||||
9 |
CHINESE TEA |
Lame off fore |
1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo) |
|
||||||||
10 |
CHICAGO STAR |
Lame off fore |
1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo) |
|
||||||||
11 |
ROYALTY’S WISH |
Cast near fore plate |
– |
– |
||||||||
11 |
HAIRY FIST |
No significant finding |
– |
– |
||||||||
12 |
SUPER ATAS |
Lame off fore |
1000M/vet (2 weeks embargo) |
– |
||||||||
Note: The above horse(s) will be required to pass the above test(s) before being declared to race again. |
||||||||||||
Fines |
Race |
Name of Licensee |
Horse Name |
Date of Fine Imposed |
Fine Amount (RM) |
MRA Rule/Regulation |
||||||
|
11 |
Jockey O Chavez |
FAMOUS NAME |
19/8/23 |
250/- |
Rule 152(5)(a) |
||||||
Suspension(s) |
R1 |
App A Suriya (NORTHERN KNIGHT) – 2 Malaysian race days for careless riding under MRA Rule 44(9)(a)(ii) |